Quick answer: in the vast majority of cases, exchange is the most reliable and cost-effective solution: a reconditioned gearbox rebuilt to 0 km costs between 639 € and 7920 € depending on the make and technology (warranty of up to 24 months), compared with €1,500 to €3,500 for a repair with uncertain results, and €400 to €1,500 for a second-hand unit with no real warranty or known history.
2026 Comparison Table
| Criterion | Exchange | Repair | Second-hand (breaker) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average price | 639 € – 7920 € | €1,500 – €3,500 | €400 – €1,500 |
| Warranty | Up to 24 months | 3 to 12 months (repaired parts only) | 0 to 3 months, often void if not fitted by a professional |
| Mileage | 0 km (fully reconditioned) | Original mileage retained | Unknown, often 150,000+ km |
| Reliability | Bench-tested before dispatch | Depends on the initial diagnosis | Complete lottery |
| Lead time | 2 to 7 working days | 1 to 3 weeks (vehicle off the road) | Variable depending on availability |
| Environmental impact | Full second life for the part | Good | Good but limited service life |
Exchange: new-unit reliability without the new-unit price
The unit is fully stripped down, every wear component replaced as standard, then the gearbox is reassembled to manufacturer tolerances and bench-tested. You receive a part rebuilt to 0 km, ready to fit, and your old gearbox is taken back (deposit refunded). At EDEN BOITES, 3487 reconditioned gearboxes are available on an exchange basis, with a warranty of up to 24 months, delivered throughout France and Europe.
Repair: appealing on paper, risky in practice
Repairing your own gearbox seems logical, but the initial diagnosis often reveals only part of the damage: once it's opened up, the bill climbs (synchros + bearings + gears), the vehicle can be off the road for weeks, and only the parts that were replaced are covered by the warranty. At around €2,000 for a repair, exchange is almost always the more sensible choice.
Second-hand: the false economy
A breaker's gearbox costs less to buy, but its history is unknown, its real mileage unverifiable, and the warranty virtually non-existent. If it fails within 6 months, you pay again for the part AND the fitting labour (€600 to €1,200). Statistically, it's the most expensive option per kilometre.
Our verdict
Repair only if the fault is minor and localised (e.g. clutch release bearing); second-hand only for a vehicle at the end of its life; exchange in all other cases. Not sure which reference is compatible with your vehicle? Get a free express quote using your number plate.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a reconditioned gearbox cost by make?
Renault: 649 to 2795 €, Volkswagen: 639 to 7920 € (DSG included), Peugeot: 698 to 2880 €, Audi: 649 to 4254 €. Exact price ranges by make are displayed in real time on each page of the shop.
Is fitting included?
No, fitting is carried out by your mechanic (allow €600 to €1,200 depending on the vehicle); the warranty requires professional installation.
What about an engine?
The same logic applies: a reconditioned engine costs from 2160 € to 13500 € depending on the engine, often less than half the price of a new unit from the manufacturer.
